Sunday, April 19, 2015

Week 14 Prompt

Libraries are trying to connect people with information, and as readers’ advisors we are trying to find books that our patrons might like but are not aware of. Separating out genre fiction, like LGBTQ and Urban, does not do much to aid either of these goals and has more negatives associated with it than positives. While having separate sections for the books could make it easier for certain patrons to go right to the section they are interested in, it also prevents people from stumbling upon new things and allows them to make a snap judgement about it. Just because a book is in the romance section doesn’t mean that it is a book with Fabio on the cover. There might be more to the story that a reader would like, but this classification might immediately turn them off before even giving it a chance. There is also an issue with classifying the books themselves. Many writers create works that may fit into multiple different genres. Just because a book has an LGBTQ character doesn’t mean that is the main subject of the work or the only thing that could identify it. “The danger that arises in separating out genre fiction in libraries is that this separation can contribute to the continued notion that there is a hierarchy of writing and that genre fiction belongs lower on the scale than literary fiction” (Trott). Not separating the genres out can also save space in libraries. Many people are seeking out the library for computer usage, study space, and community meeting rooms. Having less space devoted to books and separate sections of literature could allow the library to devote more of the building to tables, chairs, and computers for patron usage.

Resources
Trott, Barry. "A House Divided? Two Views on Genre Separation." Reference & User Services Quarterly 46.2 (n.d.): n. pag. Reference & User Services Quarterly. American Library Association, 05 Jan. 2008. Web. 19 Apr. 2015. <http://blog.rusq.org/2008/01/05/a-house-divided-two-views-on-genre-separation/>.

Urban Fiction Annotation

The Coldest Winter Ever: A Novel

By: Sister Souljah


Genre: Urban Fiction

Publication Date: April 1999

Number of Pages: 337

Geographical Setting: Brooklyn, New York

Time Period: Current Day

Plot Summary: Winter, the spoiled rotten daughter of notorious drug lord Ricky Santiago, gets caught up in her father’s dangerous world when his enemies cause harm to her family. Winter makes money by hustling stolen goods on the street and becoming entangled with a group of untrustworthy people that she crosses. After numerous fights and endless drama, Winter ends up in jail like her old man with the same foes she has been fighting.  

Subject Headings: African American women -- New York (State) -- New York -- Fiction; Inner Cities -- New York (State) -- New York -- Fiction; Brooklyn (New York, N.Y.) -- Fiction

Appeal: This gritty and violent tale about the world of street life in Brooklyn will appeal to anyone looking for a sobering work of Urban Fiction.

Read-alikes:
Confessions of a Wild Child by Jackie Collins - A fast-paced and plot driven tale about the daughter of a criminal kingpin whose father tries to protect her from a life of crime.  

Dirty to the Grave by Karen Williams - A high-drama suspenseful novel about trying to get out of the street life when someone you care for is trying to pull you back in.

Thieves’ Paradise by Eric Jerome Dickey - A fast-paced and steamy story about the highs and lows experienced when living life on the streets.

Friday, April 10, 2015

Week 13 Prompt

The idea that adults shouldn’t be reading something is absurd. Adults should read whatever they want, whether it is graphic novels, YA literature, or children’s books. Just because a story has been targeted at a certain audience doesn’t mean that a fully formed adult cannot get anything out of the story. Books like the Hunger Games series and or the Walking Dead graphic novels deserve their place on the shelves of public libraries and patrons should not be ashamed about checking them out. It is perfectly fine for people to have their own opinions about YA and choose not to read it themselves, like Ruth Graham, who wrote about her feelings in an article for Slate, but other adults who like YA should read away. In her article, Graham “...focused on what she said the publishing industry calls realistic fiction, and argued that adult readers who hew to Y.A. miss out on too much...’These books consistently indulge in the kind of endings that teenagers want to see, but which adult readers out to reject as far too simple…” (Wolitzer). While it is true that many teen stories wrap things up in a tight little bow, I fail to see why that is a problem. People read to learn things, but they also read as an escape. This is one of the reasons that I enjoy fantasy and science fiction. There are many depressing things in the world, and sometimes it is nice to read about fantastical elements, first love, and have everything conclude with a happy ending.

Resources
Wolitzer, Meg. "Look Homeward, Reader: A Not-So-Young Audience for Young Adult Books." The New York Times. N.p., 17 Oct. 2014. Web. 10 Apr. 2015. <http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/19/fashion/a-not-so-young-audience-for-young-adult-books.html?_r=0>.

Sunday, April 5, 2015

Week 12 Prompt

The Readers’ Advisory Matrix for Yes, Please, by Amy Poehler


  1. Where is the book on the narrative continuum?
    1. A mix (combines highly narrative moments with periods of fact-based prose)
  2. What is the subject of the book?
    1. Amy Poehler’s journey from childhood in suburban America to world famous stand up comedienne and actress.
  3. What type of book is it?
    1. Humorous memoir.
  4. Articulate appeal.
    1. What is the pacing of the book?
      1. Quick.
    2. Describe the characters of the book.
      1. The story focuses on Amy, and the family, classmates, and coworkers who interact with her throughout the course of her life.
    3. How does the story feel?
      1. Funny, enjoyable, endearing.
    4. What is the intent of the author?
      1. To share the experiences she went through that made her into the woman she is today.
    5. Does the language matter?
      1. Yes.
    6. Is the setting important and well described?
      1. Yes. Poehler lived in different placed during various times in her life and these environments shaped her as much as the characters she interacted with.
    7. Are the details and, if so, of what?
      1. This book features many details about the events that occurred in Poehler’s life and the emotions she felt during each stage that she went through.
    8. Are there sufficient charts and other graphical materials? Are they useful and clear?
      1. No charts or other graphic material are present in this work.
    9. Does the book stress moments of learning, understanding, or experience?
      1. Yes. One of the strengths of this book is it’s vivid descriptions of Poehler’s life, how she dealt with them, and the outcome of these various interactions.
  5. Why would a reader enjoy this book (rank appeal)?
    1. 1. Tone    2. Writing Style    3. Plot

Annotations - Nonfiction

Dead Wake: The Last Crossing of the Lusitania

By: Erik Larson


Genre: Non-fiction

Publication Date: March 10, 2015

Number of Pages: 430

Geographical Setting: United States, England, Ireland, Atlantic Ocean

Time Period: World War I

Plot Summary: While the United States was trying to stay out of World War I, the German government was trying to wreak havoc on it’s enemies with the use of Unterseeboots, also known as submarines. These U-boats had the capability to sneak up on unsuspecting ships and fire torpedoes in order to sink them to the bottom of the ocean regardless of whose flag the ship was sailing. The HMS Lusitania planned to sail from New York City to Liverpool like it had done so many times before, never dreaming that their beautiful ocean liner would be a target for German U-boat captains. Despite a pre-departure warning from the German embassy, the passengers, crew, and captain all climbed aboard dreaming of their safe arrival in Ireland a week later. Before the ship reached safe harbor a series of seemingly insignificant events occurred to bring about a terrible tragedy that would begin America’s journey into war.

Subject Headings: Lusitania (Steamship); World War 1914-1918 -- Naval Operations, Germany; Shipping -- Government Policy -- Great Britain -- History -- 20th Century


Appeal: This engaging and richly detailed work of nonfiction will keep readers turning pages late into the night in order to discover the fate of the HMS Lusitania.

Read-alikes:
Lusitania: An Epic Tragedy by Diana Preston - A compelling and descriptive tale of the Lusitania last days afloat.

Lusitania: Triumph, Tragedy, and the End of the Edwardian Age by Greg King - An engaging and richly detailed story of the the Lusitania’s sinking and the years following.

A Night to Remember by Walter Lord - A fast paced and dramatic story about the sinking of the RMS Titanic.

Sunday, March 29, 2015

Book Annotations - Historical Fiction

Gone with the Wind

By Margaret Mitchell


Genre: Historical Fiction

Publication Date: June 10, 1936

Number of Pages: 1,037

Geographical Setting: Clayton County, Georgia; Atlanta, Georgia

Time Period: United States Civil War and Reconstruction

Plot Summary: Scarlett O’Hara, a young Georgian debutante, resides on a plantation known as Tara in the American South just prior to the beginning of the Civil War. Scarlett is in love with Ashley Watkins, who is betrothed to another woman. When Scarlett declares her love for him she is rejected in front of the debonaire bachelor Rhett Butler. The Civil War starts and all of the men are called to fight, including the new husband she has just married. He dies of pneumonia shortly after the start of the war and Scarlett is left to mourn and raise their child alone. Scarlett moves to Atlanta and must face the burden of living in poverty after the burning of the South and the destruction of her childhood home, Tara. After the death of her second husband, Scarlett reunites with Rhett Butler and the two lead a posh life in Atlanta with a new child, until tragedy strikes. Scarlett and Rhett must deal with immense grief and their own marriage during the rebuilding of the South.

Subject Headings:
O’Hara, Scarlett (Fictitious Character) -- Fiction; Butler, Rhett (Fictitious Character) -- Fiction; Georgia -- History -- Civil War, 1861-1865, -- Fiction; Women -- Georgia -- Fiction

Appeal: This coming of age tale set in the American South during the Civil War period will make readers curious to find out how Scarlett O’Hara fares in this character driven, dramatic, and engaging work of historical fiction.

Read-alikes:
Belle Cora by Phillip Margulies - A richly detailed story of love, loss, and trying to obtain what you desire in historical New York City.

Rhett Butler’s People by Donald McCraig - A character driven story about the life of Rhett Butler and the people who influenced him.

White Doves at Morning by James Lee Burke - This lyrical Civil War story tells the tale of Willie Burke and his friends as they leave home to fight for the Confederate Cause.

Sunday, March 15, 2015

Book Club Experience

On Tuesday, February 10 I attended the “Fiction for Foodies” book club held by the Niles District Library in Niles, MI. I have never been to this library before and I like using class assignments as an excuse to visit library systems that I have never visited. I reached out to the group leader, who is an employee at the library, to see if they would allow to me attend and observe their discussion. The group, consisting of two library leaders and approximately six regular group members, welcomed me with open arms and were excited to have a new individual attend and bring a new viewpoint to the discussion. The group meets once a month and it is facilitated by the librarians who work there. The staff pick the books that the club will read and they decide on the list for the entire year at the end of the previous one.
For the February book club, the group was discussing The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry by Gabrielle Zevin. The group started as a way for interested individuals to get together and share good stories and good food. In the beginning all of the books the club read featured food fairly prominently in the story. As the club has progressed, they have started to choose stories that are more varied and don’t focus on food in them. Each member brings a dish to share that reminds them of the book and the club begins by gathering around the table with full plates to indulge and share their thoughts.
Once the members settle into their places with full plates the discussion can begin. The library employees print out a double sided sheet with information about the book on one side and discussion questions on the other side of the book. Having a handout like this one is a tip provided by ALA for facilitating a book discussion. They recommend groups “distribute handouts to everyone in order to refresh memories or use as talking points” (Facilitating Discussion). The employee leader pointed out the sheet and then asked what everyone thought of the book. She did not start by giving her opinion, but rather let the group go around the table and discuss their overall opinion about the chosen title. This particular start to the book discussion may not be the best one available to the leader of the group. “...I find that with many groups, the first question that gets asked is, naturally, ‘What did you think of the book?’ But once that’s answered, the group is quickly divided into the pros and cons. And all the subsequent responses to questions and topics of discussion are prefaced by statements like, ‘I really liked this book, but...’ or ‘I hated it, and...’” (Pearl). The general consensus seemed to be that most members did not care for The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry. Many of the group felt that the book was a sad a read and they would have liked to see it have a happier ending. After going around and telling their initial opinions, the group moved on to discussion about other aspects and specific details about the story. They discussed the characters and how they felt about their actions. They also discussed in great detail the mention of other works of fiction written into the story. Since the main character runs a bookstore, books end up being brought up quite often in throughout and most of them are actual published titles.
Throughout the discussion the library leader did not jump in immediately with her opinion, rather she would pose a question and let the group discuss their opinions and ideas before contributing her own thoughts to the book. The group was not critical of anyones opinions and each time someone expressed an idea, the group listened carefully without interrupting and then responded with their own opinion. This was not a group that was intimidating and everyone seemed to be comfortable sharing their thoughts throughout the meeting. Even though the library employees had prepared a list of discussion questions the group referenced the sheet only a couple of times when the discussion seemed to die down a bit and no one was volunteering a new topic for discussion. With the exception of these few moments, the discussion flowed quite easily and it was evident the group members, all of whom were women over the age of 30, had met in this capacity before and were able to easily make conversation.
The book group started at 6:30 pm and was slated to last for one hour. The group discussion lasted well past the scheduled end time and the participants kept discussing the book, along with other books and non-book related topics, until after the library itself had closed at 8:00 pm. The group was very friendly and their choice of titles was varied to get their participants to branch out and try new books. The work chosen for March was a non-fiction title that none of the participants had previously read. The group seems like it would be a fun one to attend, with lively discussion and good food. The library staff did a good job of organizing the group; they prepared questions in case of lulls in the conversation but did not require the discussion to adhere to this strict outline. This allowed the participants to discuss the book at leisure and wander off topic and back on if desired.

Resources

"Facilitating Discussion." I Love Libraries. American Library Association, n.d. Web. 15 Mar. 2015. <http://www.ilovelibraries.org/booklovers/bookclub/facilitate-discussion>.

Pearl, Nancy. "Check It Out with Nancy Pearl: Guidelines for Book Groups."Publisher's Weekly. N.p., 11 Jan. 2013. Web. 15 Mar. 2015. <http://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/columns-and-blogs/nancy-pearl/article/55454-check-it-out-with-nancy-pearl-guidelines-for-book-groups.html>.

Sunday, March 8, 2015

Special Topics Paper

Novellas are back. This once popular style of narrative publication has seen a resurgence thanks to some new trends in publishing and distribution. “Originating in Italy during the Middle Ages, the novella was based on local events that were humorous, political, or amorous in nature; the individual tales often were gathered into collections along with anecdotes, legends, and romantic tales” (The Editors of the Encyclopedia Britannica). Authors like John Steinbeck, Truman Capote,  and H.G. Wells all used this form of printed work to tell interesting tales with great success. While many authors have published some of their best known and most beloved works in this shorter format, but the popularity of the novella has waned in the twentieth century. More contemporary authors have not been mixing this shorter style in with their longer work in the same way that authors from previous generations had. “Most writers feel pressure, internal or external, to scale up or pare down to a ‘suitable’ length. In other words, revise or rewrite the novella out of existence” (Fassler). That trend has been changing, however, with the increasing popularity of eBooks. Authors are beginning to see the benefits as publishing shorter works in the e-format as stand alone works or as tie-ins to other novels.
Novellas are longer than short stories but lack the page count to truly qualify them as full length novels. They are a length that has recently proven to work well in the eBook format. “‘Kindle is a great way for authors to make different lengths of their writing available and to reach diverse audiences with their work’ said Stephen King. ‘I’m excited to be able to offer ‘Blockade Billy’ in the Kindle Store’” (Bestselling and Iconic...). The shorter format of the novella not only makes it a quicker read than a full-length novel, but also puts it as a great price point for buyers. Amazon currently has 11,250 results for the search term “novella” in the Kindle eBooks store, with genres such as romance, mystery, suspense, and more. More than 6,000 of those titles are available for under $10.00 and many of those are actually free Kindle books.  
Not only do these eBook novellas provide a quick read at a low price for buyers, but they also provide a way for authors to continue to story of characters from a novel in a way that is easily accessible to readers. There has recently been a surge in the number of novella length tie-ins to existing full length books. It is also an easy way for authors and publishers to convince readers to try out a new author for the first time. A reader may be more likely to purchase a novella from an author they have never read for a dollar or two than they would be to purchase a full length novel for more than ten dollars.There has recently been a surge in the number of novella length tie-ins to existing full length books, movies, and television series as well. The 2000s CW series Veronica Mars has a collection of eBook novella length stories that can be purchased for Kindle at a cost of $1.99 each and author Tiffany Reisz novella companion to her Original Sinner series.
Novellas are also a way for small and independent publishing houses to put out a greater number of works on a regular basis and make a good deal of money for their businesses. The more recent increases in self-publishing also lends greater support to the novella length as an eBook. “Ebooks do seem to be the primary venue for novellas lately, but I still think there’s a place for them in print. Novellas never used to have the commercial stigma they do today. The Old Man and the Sea, Fahrenheit 451, Animal Farm… many of our most enduring classics are novellas and would probably be rejected by today’s publishers who are constantly pushing the needle from art toward commerce” (Charman-Anderson).
Novellas are also an art form of their own that require some skill on the part of the author to craft a story that can come full circle in less time. They allow authors to express their creative vision without having to finish an entire novel. “The smoke and mirrors, rabbits and hats are more self-consciously applied than in the full-length novel. The novella is the modern and post-modern form par excellence” (McEwan). This format has showcased the writing talents of many great authors throughout the years and its resurgence in popularity gives current authors the ability to flex their creative muscles in more ways than before.
In more recent literary history the novella has been the underdog in the publishing world, reviled by publishers as something that did not fit in with the current publishing models. “Mid-length works suffer from a koan-like criticism: They’re too short and they’re also too long. Novellas hog too much space to appear in magazines and literary journals, but they’re usually too slight to release as books” (Fassler). This trend is changing and the popularity of eBooks and their easy distribution model is allowing the author, independent and self-publishers more freedom to publish what they want rather than what the major publishing houses say will sell. As a result, eBooks are putting more options in the hands of the readers and many are making the choice to embrace the novella again.


Resources

Charman-Anderson, Suw. "The Novella Economy: Making Novellas Profitable." Forbes. N.p., 29 Aug. 2013. Web. 06 Mar. 2015. <http://www.forbes.com/sites/suwcharmananderson/2013/08/29/the-novella-economy-making-novellas-profitable/>.

"Bestselling and Iconic Author Stephen King Publishes New Novella 'Blockade Billy,' Available in the Kindle Store." Mental Health Weekly Digest 3 May 2010: 615. Science in Context. Web. 8 Mar. 2015.

The Editors of the Encyclopedia Britannica. "Novella." Encyclopedia Britannica. N.p., n.d. Web. 06 Mar. 2015. <http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/421114/novella>.

Fassler, Joe. "The Return of the Novella, the Original #Longread." The Atlantic. The Atlantic Monthly Group, 24 Apr. 2012. Web. 06 Mar. 2015. <http://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2012/04/the-return-of-the-novella-the-original-longread/256290/>.

McEwan, Ian. "Some Notes on the Novella." The New Yorker. Conde Nast, 29 Oct. 2012. Web. 06 Mar. 2015. <http://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/some-notes-on-the-novella>.

Sunday, March 1, 2015

Week Seven Prompt

It’s no surprise that a woman with an average of 48 million viewers each week can increase the sale numbers for a book she recommends (Jacobson). Oprah Winfrey’s Book Club has had a measurable effect on the popularity of each work she has chosen to feature.  Only a few of the books ever cracked the USA Today bestsellers list before being chosen for the club, but “after being selected, each book joined the top 150 best-selling titles in American for at least a few months” (Butler, 23). If you are an author, hearing that you are being chosen by this media giant as part of her book club likely means great things for the future of your work. The book suddenly has instant clout with an entirely new group of people who may not have ever read another word you’ve written. This sounds like a dream come true, but the experience wasn’t universally loved by all the authors involved.  
Jonathan Franzen, author of the critically-acclaimed and Oprah endorsed book The Corrections, was not thrilled to be included in her club. “But after Mr. Franzen publicly disparaged Oprah Winfrey’s literary taste...he found that he may have inadvertently damaged his own reputation in the literary world. Ms. Winfrey did not revoke her selection but politely withdrew the invitation to appear on her show. And instead of rallying to Mr. Franzen, most of the literary world took her side, deriding him as arrogant and ungrateful” (Kirkpatrick). Mr. Franzen did not agree with Oprah’s book choices, but despite his annoyance at the situation, his sales increased on the already popular work. “...Ms. Winfrey’s selection may have been worth more than $1.5 million to Mr. Franzen” (Kirkpatrick).
As an author it seems like the end goal is getting your work into the hands of potential readers. Celebrity book clubs like this one are a great way for new audiences to hear about books by authors they may not have discovered on their own. There are people who don’t consult their libraries for readers’ advisory and don’t look at reviews to get recommendations, so this is just another way for them to gain information about new written works and for the author to try and appeal to a new, larger audience. It seems to be a win, win situation for the readers and the writers, regardless of your personal opinions about Oprah herself.

Resources

Butler, Richard J., Benjamin W. Cowan, and Sebastian Nilsson. "From Obscurity to Bestseller: Examining the Impact of Oprah’s Book Club Selections." Publishing Research Quarterly 20.4 (2005): 23-34.Academic Search Premier. Web. 01 Mar. 2015. <http://web.a.ebscohost.com.proxy.ulib.uits.iu.edu/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=2&sid=fe841cb4-1096-4826-bf91-ed951bf7dd82%40sessionmgr4004&hid=4206>.

Jacobson, Murrey. "The Oprah Effect, by the Numbers." The Rundown. PBS, 25 May 2011. Web. 01 Mar. 2015. <http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/the-oprah-phenomenon-by-the-numbers/>.

Kirkpatricks, David D. "'Oprah' Gaffe By Franzen Draws Ire And Sales." The New York Times [New York] 29 Oct. 2001, Books sec.: n. pag. The New York Times. Web. 01 Mar. 2015. <http://www.nytimes.com/2001/10/29/books/oprah-gaffe-by-franzen-draws-ire-and-sales.html>.

Friday, February 27, 2015

Annotations - Science Fiction

The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy

By: Douglas Adams


Genre: Science Fiction

Publication Date: September 02, 1989 (first published in 1979)

Number of Pages: 224

Geographical Setting: Earth, Milky Way Galaxy, Magrathea

Time Period: Future

Series: The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, Book One

Plot Summary: Planet Earth is about to be demolished to make way for the new galactic freeway when Arthur Dent is saved by his friend Ford Prefect. The two end up on a ship full of members from the alien race Vogon who force them to listen to terrible poetry before dumping them into space. The two are rescued from impending doom by the Heart of Gold, a ship owned by the President of the Galaxy, Zaphod. Arthur and Ford join Zaprod, a depressed robot named Marvin, and a woman called Trillian as they travel across the galaxy to the planet Magrathea and a giant computer named Deep Throat who reveals the ultimate answer to everything.

Subject Headings: Prefect, Ford; Dent, Arthur (Fictitious Character)

Appeal: This humorous work of science fiction will appeal to anyone who enjoy quirky tales set in the future. The colorful characters and the trouble they encounter will have readers eager to read the further adventure of this motley crew.

Read-alikes:
The Lathe of Heaven by Ursula K. Le Guin - Dreams really can change the world in this disturbing and thought provoking work of science fiction.

The Ascent of Rum Doodle by W.E. Bowman - Hijinks and hilarity ensue when a group of mountain climbers wage war on the neighboring Mount Rum Doodle in this humorous adventure story.

Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? by Philip K. Dick - This thought provoking, dystopian tale set on a future Earth showcases a battle between android robots and those who banished them from the planet.  



Saturday, February 21, 2015

Week 6 Prompt

In order to promote the circulation of romance novels at the library, I would like to create an eye catching display on an end cap near the front entrance. It is the season of romance with Valentine’s Day upon us and a well done display could encourage patrons to check out a book about love, lust, and more. “Book displays are the most effective way to recommend books. Standing books up on a lower table is boring and suggests that books are insignificant. Effective displays will recommend the books by being located where the display will be seen; will attract the eye with color and signage and making the books important” (Rippel). The display will have a brightly colored background in pinks, purples, and reds in order to catch attention. Decorative lettering will be used to create a sign stating “Fall in Love with a Good Book”. The display will feature a variety of romance books displayed both on shelves attached to the end cap and a small table placed against it. The end cap will also have a list of suggested romance novels to provide passive readers’ advisory to individuals looking for a romance to take home and enjoy.

Resources

Rippel, Chris. "What Libraries Can Learn from Bookstores." What Libraries Can Learn from Bookstores. OCLC Web Junction, 10 Sept. 2003. Web. 21 Feb. 2015. <http://www.webjunction.org/documents/webjunction/What_Libraries_Can_Learn_from_Bookstores.html>.

Sunday, February 15, 2015

Week 5 Prompt

The world of self publishing, eBook only publications, and print on demand has made librarians working in collection development rethink the way they consider materials for their library. Just because an item has not been picked up by a major publishing house and given a print run does not mean that it is a valuable work of literature or that it isn’t worthy of being added to the collection. The Fifty Shades of Grey trilogy by E.L. James is a good example of this. “James, a former TV executive based in London, published the first installment of the Fifty Shades trilogy as an e-book. Without traditional distribution by a big-name publisher in the United States, the series caught on via word-of-mouth and Facebook” (Fay). These books have proved to be extremely popular in library systems that have them and have now been turned into a big screen adaptation. When it comes to items that are only published as eBooks, or items that are self published, collection development librarians can still turn to reviews in order to judge whether or not the item is a good fit for their collection. The reviews may just be of a different sort than the the professional reviews published for big name authors and those represented by major publishing houses. “...Clark explained how she currently assesses self-published material on Amazon, for example--she looks for books whose reviews show that the reader really pondered the book and whose fans are geographically dispersed…” (On).


The Billionaire's First Christmas
The reviews for this book were both written by romance readers and, while far from professional quality, do give the opinions of people who are the target audience for this item. These individuals have grammatical and spelling errors present throughout their reviews, but they do give an accurate picture of what they thought of the book. The reviews are reliable in that they give the true opinion of these readers, but I’m not sure they would be convincing enough on their own to make a decision about whether or not to purchase this romance for my library system. These reviews, in addition to sales and rank numbers on Amazon, might be enough to convince the addition of this item to the collection.


Angela’s Ashes
This book, written by Frank McCourt, is one that I have personally read and thoroughly enjoyed. McCourt’s story is one of heartbreak and triumph and the author does a great job of telling the tale in a way that is enticing to readers. All four of the reviews give a positive overview of this memoir and all highlight different aspects of the book. The Library Journal review gives more of an overview while the Booklist and School Library Journal reviews give a few more specific details about elements from the story. All of these reviews would be helpful in making a decision about this item and would encourage collection development librarians to add this book to their library’s collection.


Reviews can be extremely important to the collection development department when making decisions about what to purchase. I have spent some time working with acquisitions in my own library and they do look at Library Journal, Booklist, and other review publications in order to help them make decisions. It is fine if certain publications don’t want to publish negative reviews, but it is important for libraries to look at sources that do publish them in order to gather as much information as possible when making collection development decisions.


This is not the only thing they consult however, because reviews are only part of the equation. Just because an item is really well reviewed does not mean that it will be a book that your readers will be interested in and just because a book has bad reviews does not mean your patrons won’t want it. There are many books that are not great works of literature destined to become classics that are extremely popular with patrons and that is just fine. Patrons should read what they like and the library should provide those materials for them. Ultimately the most important opinion to take into consideration when purchasing material is that of the patron. “Customer use is the most powerful influence on the Library’s collection. Circulation, customer purchase requests and holds levels are all closely monitored, triggering purchase of new items and additional copies of high demand items” (Collection Development Policy). If a book gets terrible reviews but your patrons want to read it, the library should make sure it has plenty of copies on hand to meet their users demands.


In general I do not tend to look at reviews when I am making decisions about my own reading choices. I have access to Library Journal and Booklist through work and do look at these publications each month. Occasionally these items will feature a book I had not heard about and their reviews will prompt me to read an item. I just finished recently finished reading Empire of Sin: A Story of Sex, Jazz, Murder, and the Battle for Modern New Orleans by Gary Krist because I saw it in a “Best of 2014” list by Library Journal. Most often though I read a book because I am interested in it regardless of what reviews say about it.


Resources


"Collection Development Policy." Denver Public Library, May 2014. Web. 15 Feb. 2015. <http://denverlibrary.org/content/collection-development-policies>.


Fay, Sarah. "After 'Fifty Shades of Grey,' What's Next for Self-Publishing?"The Atlantic. The Atlantic Monthly Group, 02 Apr. 2012. Web. 15 Feb. 2015. <http://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2012/04/after-fifty-shades-of-grey-whats-next-for-self-publishing/255338/>.

On, Henrietta Verma. "Collection Development 2020: Library Journal's Day of Dialogue." Library Journal (n.d.): n. pag. 30 May 2013. Web. 15 Feb. 2015. <http://reviews.libraryjournal.com/2013/05/collection-development/collection-development-2020-library-journals-day-of-dialog/>.